MaltaMedia Click Here!
Wired Malta
  A blog from the MaltaMedia Online Network  | MAIN PAGE | NEWS | WHAT'S ON | FEATURES | WEATHER | CONTACT ROBERT

Tuesday, February 15, 2005

The Malta - Lebanon connection

World news coverage was dominated yesterday by the shocking car explosion that killed former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri in an assassination in west Beirut. It brings to mind the historical and cultural relationship between Lebanon and Malta, two peoples that have a lot in common.

Raymond Dibb's curiosity about the Maltese language, which started in a New York lift, prompted him to conduct research about the historical links between Malta and lebanon. His enthusiasm for Pheonician history led him to set up a Malta - Lebanon friendship society with a view to enhance ties between the Maltese and Lebanese People, to explore their common heritage, and encourage research, exchanges, and visits between the two Mediterranean countries. To discover his own Pheonician roots he visited Malta for the first time in the summer of 2002. He made a number of discoveries:

The Maltese are Phoenicians who came from Lebanon some 3,000 years BC. Some Phoenicians also arrived Malta from Carthage years later, during or after the Punic Wars with the Romans. These were warriors as opposed to the original Phoenicians who were just peaceful traders. The Maltese have little or no idea (or interest) in their roots. In fact very little of their history is recorded, or preserved before the Knights of Malta.

The Maltese think their language is a mix of "Arabic" and Italian. I tried very hard to explain to the ones I met, that it is not really Arabic; rather it is Phoenician having similar roots to Arabic.
They still speak the Phoenician language of the "old, old" days. It is very hard to understand by some Phoenician like me, whose language has been mixed with classical Arabic. Theirs was mixed (10%) with the Sicilian dialect.

Their spoken language sounds more like the language of the Lebanese mountains and remote Lebanese-Syrian villages, where they have not learned to sophisticate their speech with classical Arabic pronunciations. I had hard time understanding the Maltese speech, but was at ease with the written words. For example "Jelleb ta'l Carrob" means "Debs el-Kharnoub". I loved the "Jelleb" part, but it seemed they had no clue about our use of the word "Jelleb". It was very hot, and at every place I went to for refreshment, I kept asking if they had "Jelleb" over ice. I must have sounded like an alien since they do not know the Lebanese way of drinking Jelleb.

They have some very familiar family names such as "Abu Hagar" (Abou Hajar), Micallef, Mintoff, and, believe it or not "Saliba". I was amazed to learn that my cousin "John Saliba" practiced law in Malta. Any way, there are some 375,000 people living in Malta, divided into only 895 family names (and that include some English Colonial, as well as old emigrant Sicilian, and possibly some remnant Knights family names). Their phone book is very interesting; each family name takes up many pages. I guess these were a "few" Phoenician clans who migrated centuries, or millennia ago, and just kept on inter-breeding.

The National Geographic reports on a study by The American University of Beirut proving a DNA link between Pheonicians and Maltese.

Anonymous Linguist said...

Congratulations on your blog. It is fun and informative. Just one comment

Regarding the Maltese language amd despite of

a. any strained theories struggling to link the Maltese language with Lebanese Arabic (which in turn can hardly be linked to Phoenician, despite Christian Maronites' beliefs),

b. arbitrary percentages (e.g. mixed (10%) with the Sicilian dialect)

c. unscientific turns of phrase such as mixed itself or the naive to sophisticate their speech with classical Arabic pronunciationshere is the received wisdom, the result of long and detailed studies on the Maltese language, as recorded in one of the most respected sources in comparative and typological linguistics:

http://www.ethnologue.com/show_language.asp?code=MLS

All the best,

a linguist 

Monday, February 21, 2005 11:12:00 PM
Blogger Roderick Mallia said...

This Phoenician-Maltese link is quite interesting to say the least. Malta being the small island that it is has inevitably managed to quite literally soak up influences from the whole of the Mediterranean basin.

I had a look on Dibb's site however I must disagree with the comments on family names. Research has clearly shown that more than 90% of Maltese surnames are of Sicilian (major) or Italian (minor) decent. Sicilians like Maltese are quite a mixed lot as well so I appreciate the fact that some Phoenician traits might have been handed down to us by the Sicilians as well. But personally I tend to associate us Maltese more with Siclians than with anyone else. Even the first colonisers of the Maltese islands were found to be Sicilians.

And language-wise I find it hard to believe that Maltese has been mixed with a mere 10% Sicilian. A recent study on the Maltese lexicon proved that over 50% of words are of Italian/Sicilian origin, with Arabic coming a close second (was published last year on the Times of Malta). Now I don't really understand Arabic or Phoenician but I can recognize a word derived from Italian anytime. And I think Maltese is nearly equally divided between Italian-derived words and Arabic (Phoenician) words.

I'm having a look at that National Geographic link you left on your site Robert (Thanks for the link by the way). Interesting stuff. I might try and search for the relevant paper or any similar studies when I have time since this topic has interested me for quite some time. 

Sunday, June 12, 2005 12:42:00 AM
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I consider the Phoenician connection with the Maltese people rather like a folktale. The Phoenicians, an extinct people of more than 2000 years ago, had a bearing on Maltese people when there been have numerous other people from outside Malta who have sojourned there in more recent historic times. What about the Romans or the Byzantine Greeks or those supposedly chaste Knights?
So far I have read a lot of rubbish linking Maltese with Phoenicians or Arabs without any genetic proof in a published science journal on genetics. Even the Melungeons in the USA claim links to Malta by "blood". Roderick Mallia indicated that all humans who eventually came to live in Malta came via Sicily. I believe that. The Megalith builders, even those folkloric Phoenicians came from Sicily. In the Sicilian island of Motya, the Phoenicians had an extensive habitation including a tophet. In Malta the Phoenicians left nothing like Motya or the Punic remains in Tunisia.
It is about time Maltese people reclaim their history and stop foreigners coming up with elementary school ideas about the origins of the Maltese people or their language. 

Thursday, March 02, 2006 5:11:00 PM
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It is not unlike the Leb christian Arabs, who have an inferiority complex, to perpetuate these sort of lies and myths. Further, they haev the money to aid corrupt, pseudo-scientific journals like the National Geographic, as they get a lot of money from Saudi Arabia for shady reasons. Maltese is not at all similar to Phoenician, and if there is any link with Phoenicia it surely would have come from Tunisia, a country in closer proximity and whose language is very close to Maltese. I am always amazed, however, by the efforts Lebs make to spread their propaganda. I have heard of the study that was conducted and I am not convinced. No annotations are available,and it was a study financed by El Hariri, a well-known corrupt billionaire who is believed to be the son of the Saudi Arabia late king. 

Monday, September 24, 2007 9:37:00 PM
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I do not claim to be a linguist but being an Arabic speaker I have absolutly no problem understanding Maltese when we visit the island.
Attempts to distance Maltese from Arabic are a joke and only fuel the "flavour of the month" anti-Arab and Islamophobic attitudes prevelant currently in the EU.
Shame on you all - but you can not run away from the Arabic blood running throgh your veins !
Try a blood transfusion mayber in Sweden? How about the Arabic genes???? 

Thursday, December 27, 2007 10:27:00 PM
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I agree with the previous poster. I'm a native Arabic speaker from Lebanon (and Christian to boot). I visted Malta 5 years ago. Since then I've studied the language. I can safely say that it is Arabic mixed with a Romance language with later influences from French and English.

The standard of 'scholarship' that's espoused by some of my countrymen (in order to boost feel-good theories) is appalling! Had Mr. Dib bothered to learn Phoenician, he would find it to be much closer to Hebrew than Classical or Modern Arabic. Lebanese is clearly much closer to Classical Arabic than Classical or Modern Hebrew. Many of the Lebanese & Malti words he claims are Pheonician are pure Arabic with very different Hebrew/Phoenician equivalents.

Having said that, it is very likely that Malti, like Lebanese has a few remnants from Canaanite/Phoenician. That would be a very natural thing given the similar histories (Phoenician langauage as a substrate on top of which Arabic was imposed). Malta was a major Phoenician colony and likely heavily settled by them. It retained its Punic speech throughout the Roman period even as Latin was the dominant governing language. During the 2 centuries of Arab invasion, the Arabic language supplanted the original Semitic tongue precisely because they are organically very similar.

But to deny the fundamental Arabic nature of both Lebanese and Malti is ridiculous!

I commend Mr. Dib however for doing much to open up new avenues of cross-Mediterranean awareness. We really are much closer to each other, linguistically, culturally and even genetically than today's states and nations would make us believe. However, he does not need to use shoddy linguistics to prove a point (that there is a strong Phoenician history in Malta that affected its culture, language and possibly genetics) that no one is contesting in the first place!

Mike Haddad 

Tuesday, July 08, 2008 1:47:00 AM
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm not a linguist either, and not a 'Leb propagandist' in any shape or form, but as a 'Leb' I can understand Maltese. Perhaps someone has a better explanation then.

As for saying that Maltese should be proud of their heritage, in case they haven't noticed, the entire Mediterranean basin was ruled...by just about everyone in the are at one point or another. If that's not something to be proud of in terms of cultural heritage, not sure what is. 

Monday, August 18, 2008 12:36:00 AM
Anonymous michel said...

i would like to answer on anonymous 2: I m Christian Lebanese, and i dont have any inferiority complex, i m proud to be born in my land, the land of Jesus christ, the land where muslims and christians are living happely together long time ago, the land of the phonecians who created alphabet and the land of the arabs who where elite in science and medicine (read history). and totally agree with you that El Hariri is a corrupted politician, but very few people support him in lebanon, and he would never be in power without the american support unfortunatly. Lebanese people are free people not related to any other country like SAUDI Arabia...Dont judge a poeple because of a person, go to Lebanon and you will know what i m talking about. Michel. 

Sunday, February 15, 2009 1:23:00 PM

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home